|
HOUSES OF
WORSHIP
A Jewish Lourdes
Revisited
Who will help the
once-robust synagogues of Egypt?

BY LUCETTE LAGNADO
Friday, June 10, 2005 12:01 a.m. EDT
CAIRO--Maimonides, the great rabbi, philosopher and healer,
died 800 years ago in Egypt, but for many of those years he kept
on working. Over the centuries his presence was said to be felt
in the little synagogue deep in the heart of Cairo's old Jewish
Quarter where, legend had it, he taught his disciples in a
basement room. For the Jews of the Levant, Maimonides the doctor
was as important as Maimonides the theologian and codifier of
Jewish law. So it was to his small shul, known as Rav
Moshe, that Jews from across Egypt journeyed in hopes that the
man who believed in both God and science could cure them.
As it happens, I once went to this Jewish Lourdes as a little
girl. When I was six, there was a small sleeping area in Rav
Moshe, with worn-out mattresses. Anyone who came to be healed
was handed a threadbare blanket and a pillow, and perhaps some
holy rubbing oil, and urged to go to sleep and wait for the
Rambam, as Maimonides was called. As a child, I was terrified of
the place: It was so dark and spooky. But legend had it that
once you were asleep, Maimonides would visit you in a dream and
heal you. I was suffering at the time from a puzzling swelling
in my left leg that mystified all the specialists my parents
consulted.
I have no idea if Maimonides made one of his "house calls"
for me. But I do know that my symptoms abated. My crisp,
rational American upbringing in the decades since hasn't
entirely cured me of my faith in the unseen hand of Maimonides
and his presence in the little temple in the ghetto. Thus I
wanted to pay my respects last month, when I visited Cairo some
40 years after my family had left in the diaspora that followed
the flight of the Jews from Nasser's Egypt, a community once
80,000-strong.
Even in 2005, the old Jewish Quarter is a maze of alleyways
where one must look out for donkeys, chickens and hungry cats.
As my husband and I followed our guide on foot, schoolchildren
joined us, delighted to see Americans on their turf. If there is
anti-Americanism in Cairo, or anti-Semitism, I didn't see it in
the children.
Or in the adults either. I knew that we had arrived at our
destination when I saw an armed guard on patrol. Cairo has many
Jewish houses of worship where no worship has taken place in
decades. Yet these abandoned hulks are fiercely protected. The
Nasser regime may have thrown out Egypt's Jews, but the Mubarak
regime seems to be devoting immense resources to protecting what
remains of their legacy.
Still, Rav Moshe is a shambles. The roof of the sanctuary
where I had prayed as a child caved in years ago. What survives
is the ark that once housed the Torah scrolls. I wanted to see
the shrine but had to stop. The basement was flooded. I stepped
across a plank and stood on a bench in the room where I had
slept as a child. There were no blankets or mattresses now, no
holy oil, no Maimonides.
The former chief Sephardic Rabbi of Israel cited the term
"orphans" when analyzing what to do with holy objects left
behind in Egypt. In Judaism, prayer books, Torah scrolls--even
their covers and decorations--are not simply sacred but also
alive. Left unused, they are like bereaved children, and that's
how they seemed to me on my visit to Cairo, not just at Rav
Moshe but at one vacant synagogue after another.
Even Shar Hashamaim, a grand synagogue in downtown Cairo--the
name means "the Gates of Heaven"--looks desperately faded with
its rows upon rows of empty pews. Entering the synagogue can be
an intimidating affair. Armed guards swarmed around nervously as
we drove up. Yet they were kind during our tour, and some put
down their weapons. Once inside, I ran to the ark and lifted the
curtains, hoping to kiss the Torah scrolls. The ark was
padlocked, and I was directed to one small scroll on display.
At some point Cairo's Jewish institutions became hostage to a
grim dispute between local caretakers and expatriate Egyptian
Jews. On one side, Jews in New York, led by Desi Sakkal, a Cairo
expatriate, argued for the removal of the sacred objects so that
they could be used again. But the few Jews left in Cairo
contended with equal fervor that it was wrong to loot Egypt of
its treasures. As the debate raged, the synagogues became ever
more decrepit.
Like Temple Hanan, the synagogue where my father once
worshipped. It had been a palatial structure, with vaulted
ceilings, chandeliers, high windows and a spacious courtyard.
Now it looked haunted, shabby and unbearably sad. Its ark, too,
was padlocked.
 It would take a great rabbi to decide whether Egypt's Judaica
should stay or leave. It may even be too late, said Raphael
Benchimol, a New York rabbi at the Manhattan Sephardic
Congregation. He worries that the Torah scrolls may be so frayed
that some are unusable and may have to be "buried," as we would
bury loved ones.
But repairing Rav Moshe and other temples should be
relatively simple. Imagine Egyptians and Westerners working side
by side to rebuild a small Jewish house of worship--maybe
several. That would be a miracle worthy of the Rambam.
Ms. Lagnado, a Journal reporter, is working on a memoir of
her father for Ecco/HarperCollins
|